20 December 2012

行动党吃掉自已口号



  
对多元种族政治抱持着美好愿景的人,行动党党选终究令他们对客观事实长叹和无奈。该党63名竞逐中央的6位马来人,无一可以挤进20个阵容的中委会,1826名中央代表以华为尊,根本不考虑融入多元种族色彩。

在非华裔当中,卡巴星父子若不是凭藉累积的声望和大选逼近因素,也许会在这股黄潮中淹没。卡巴星选前提醒中央代表勿忘元老功劳,意图延续他的政治生命直到告老。虽然他以第三高票当选且连任党主席,那只是大选前维护党内团结门面的布局。党选不是上道德课,没有敬老尊贤和怀缅感恩这回事。

原署理主席陈胜尧被挤出中委会,不敢说明被干掉的原因,深恐晚节不保。这也说明长江后浪推前浪,旧浪晒死在沙滩上。只有像林吉祥懂得玩弄权术,排挤与他同期的同僚逐个出局,才能过关斩将,屺立不倒。

林吉祥为行动党喊了"马来西亚人的马来西亚"口号46年,行动党理应呈现"马来西亚人的行动党"以符合多元种族色彩。但是,从行动党的领导层结构和斗争取向,它始终无从摆脱"华人的行动党"这一个挂羊头卖狗肉的标识。即使林冠英执政槟州对马来社会特别关照以抚慰马来社群,马来人不会因此改观。

25年党龄的祖基菲里,在改选中仅获得216票,与前20名中选者至少8百多张票的门槛简直高不可攀。他认为,国阵的结构其实已运作了"马来西亚人的马来西亚"理念,行动党改选必须认真反映所鼓吹的理念。

林吉祥和林冠英授意要上议员阿里芬中选,他仅得区区348票,可见得林氏父子口惠而实不至。执掌党内大权的林氏父子并不热衷推广多元种族色彩,因为行动党已是他们家族产业。

308过后,行动党气势如虹,具备条件号召和吸引巫裔入党,但是,上届中委阿末顿在此次改选中黯然落马,显示领导层对他不屑一顾。早前,一个可以作为擦亮行动党招牌的东姑阿都阿兹也给林冠英气走,看来,行动党已错失招揽巫裔的良机。

新届中委会以固打方式委任上议员阿里芬和林冠英政治秘书再里进入中央点缀多元色彩,但这一动作,无法摘下行动党的华人沙文主义标签,国阵将以行动党的种族主义,煽动马来社会继续对它蔑视。林吉祥狠批国阵政府在经济、商业、教育和就业领域等等实施固打制,但在本身的党选中却把他们所痛恨的政策发挥得淋漓尽致。

行动党长期受到巫统攻讦它的种族主义,主要是它的多元种族色彩外表却行单元之实。巫统、伊斯兰党表明为马来族群和宗教展开斗争,而马华的纯华人色彩以华社权益挂帅。但行动党的多元种族色彩却严重倾斜,吃掉自已的口号。

林冠英对党选反映出排挤巫裔的指控力图消毒或许会越描越黑,再多的粉饰动作也改变不了既成事实。对林冠英而言,槟城接近半数的马来选民将因此怨根深植心中,影响了他的形象。马来报章和巫统领袖打蛇随棍上炒作上述课题 ,它的盟党公正党和伊斯兰党要如何替它开脱,看来会面对词穷理极的窘境。

光明日报专栏  是非如流 20-12-2012

26 comments:

Thiam Teck (1983 - ?) said...

我想,行動黨的問題在於非華裔黨員人數不多。東姑阿都阿茲的退黨的確是很大的衝擊。華裔黨員多,然後華裔領袖佔主流,然後更難吸引非華裔黨員。成了惡性循環。

至於黨選成績,民主的運作本來就是尊重票選成績。難道黨選也要種族固打制?

Anonymous said...

Dear Thaim Teck,

U r right about the part where election its a result of democracy. however the point is that, the party central delegates show absolutely zero tolerate towards non chinese candidate.

this is far worse than 種族固打制. dont you think so?

Thiam Teck (1983 - ?) said...

hi Anonymous,

首先,除了作者提到的卡巴星父子之外,還有古拉也是非華裔的入選中委。沒有巫裔當選的確是個隱憂。但必須先探討沒有巫裔當選的原因。

如果巫裔敗選,是因為投票者純粹看膚色而拒絕他們。那的確不是好事。這種情況下,推行固打制也可以接受。(例如一些政黨對女性委員所設下的固打)。

反之,若巫裔參選者不受代表青睞是因為膚色意外的原因,例如聲望、能力等因素不如其他參選者,那就不該勉強。否則對其他參選者不公平。

我不是行動黨員,不知道當中原因。但他們既然做了這個投票決定,就該承受之後的結果。因此這些質疑之聲也是不能逃避的。就看他們怎麼處理吧。

Anonymous said...

Hi Thiam Teck,

sorry i spelt ur name wronly previously

i think by saying "I are not a DAP member" is a easier way to deny the fact that the party is flawed, if not a fraud.

there is a 26years exp grass root member, dedicated his life to the party and he won 200 odds votes. other vocal member like Dr boo and Teng barely make it into top 20.

how can u stil trying so hard to rationalise such cronyism?

Steve said...

First of all, this is an election for central executive council, which is the core group of the party leaders who will need to lead the party to fight the coming GE13. It is not about choosing the most loyal member or your personal favourite person. Perhaps you can do that at the branch level, but certainly not in something as important as CEC. I am sure that some(if not most) DAP delegates have voted based on this rational reason.

Lastly to say, I am not a DAP member(too).

Thiam Teck (1983 - ?) said...

hi anonymous,

如果我們談的是行動黨裡的裙帶主義,我不會反對。我也認為這些年來,行動黨在內鬥內行方面是有目共睹。對於這些搞小圈子、排擠異議派之類的情況,我也不打算說什麼『其他政黨也有派系鬥爭,互相排擠』之類的話,否則就等於向『民聯也會貪污』這些言論看齊了。

但文章提到的,是行動黨排擠巫裔。假設26年黨齡的代表被排擠,是和巫程豪、鄧章欽被排擠一般都是裙帶主義的問題,那問題就是當權派排擠反對派,而不是華裔排擠非華裔。

當然,我不排除這是當權派和異議派(或南馬,北馬之類的)一起排擠巫裔代表的結果。但要證實真偽,有相當難度,即使我是黨員也未必看得出端倪。

Anonymous said...

Dear Steve,

have u even wonder, why limiting the voiting for Central Executive Committee? why not give the central delegate a choice to vote for the desired president?

Dear Thiam Teck,

u are absolutely spot on. that is exactly what i was trying to say. a party that emphasize so much of CAT is breeding cronyism and racism even within the party. how can u trust these people to rule the country?

一针 said...

选择!
懂吗?

让人民多一个选择。
让两个阵线在施政上斗个你死我活,老百姓就会渔翁得利。

要不然那500令吉250令吉100令吉从何来?又何必等五十年多后才姗姗来迟?这还只是个最简单最粗浅的例子。

贪污、朋党、滥权、裙帶。。。。就尽量让新贵们学目前那些不要脸的政客吧,那是人性。
只要人民聪明一点,时辰一到,他党内不自断,人民也会帮他斩掉,顺带把党也斩掉。这就是有选择和无选择之分。难道这些政客天真到以为还有一个又一个的个五十年吗?

-一针--

Thiam Teck (1983 - ?) said...

Hi Anonymous,

對於行動黨中的裙帶主義我們的意見可說是接近的。而種族主義方面,我想我們是從不同的角度去看。也許你是從投票結果得出當中有種族主義的結論。而我比較在意的是得出這個投票結果的成因。

對於成因,我無法一口咬定或一口否定任何原因。但我可以分享一些可以討論的問題。

首先,孤陋寡聞的我,對於行動黨的領袖,我實在想不出多少個馬來人。這是行動黨的敗筆。問題是,這種情況下,沒有馬來人當選不是很正常嗎?

其次,如果為了讓行動黨黨選的成績看起來很多元而硬硬推菜單。而且還成功得到一個和諧得很假的成績。你猜猜『行動黨更趨多元』和『林氏父子罔顧民主精神,一手遮天』哪一個會更響亮?

接下來我們談談你所說的信任。民主政治的制度,本來就是因為我們不信任任何人和政黨。因為沒有政黨是完美的。與其痴痴地等一個政黨和變好,不如行使自己的權力去拒絕一個腐敗不長進的執政黨。

因此如果我把票投給民聯,不是因為他們好得天上有地下無,而是目前的執政黨有口皆碑的不稱職。

如果檳城、雪州、吉打、吉蘭丹的選民覺得他們的州政府不稱職,我也認為他們不妨再換一次。

Steve said...

Dear Anonymous,

Every organisation has their own system. Why don't you wonder about direct voting to choose our PM/president for Malaysia?

Anonymous said...

Dear "one niddle",

ya life is about choice. cant argue on that. however lets be realistic, is the present alternative better than what we have now? we can talk about corruption forever, we can write a book or heck we can make a movie about it. but bottom line is, i had never seen a barber shop closed down, liquor shop closed down ( apart from legal reason) or religious altar torn down.

do u recall what was dr xavier jayakumar responses when the altar was torn down? or waht YB anthony loke said about the hudud?

is these weak attempt or excuses u expect from your beloved party?

get a grib my friend.

Anonymous said...

Hi steve,

i am always a big fan of direct voting of PM. i guess the feeling is mutual with the PR.

however i can also tell u many things that i like about PR's proposed idea. its just that, the never actually practise it within parties or the state that are controlling.

Mmm... Mmm...

一针 said...

以目前一马台面上的政治水准,除了几个受人尊敬的政治人物,无论那一边的政客言论,都只能当着看随剧百变的猴戏,不能当真。

Beloved party? 我无党无派,任何一个政党能真真正正先把老百姓放在第一位,那就是我beloved的party。抢手们最好能明白这一点,才不会胡乱签标更多的中间选民,帮党倒老米。

你老哥英明神武、眼光远大,专注民族宗教文化大课题。我只是一般的市侩,满口铜臭。。。。。。
八十亿令吉PKFZ。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
5亿令吉潜水艇服务费
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
2.5億令吉养牛门。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
四千万令吉沙巴政治献金。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
一令吉一平方尺卖廿四块地。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
那该死无耻的地毯商毁谤大家敬爱的尊贵的一马首相及“第一马”夫人。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
普通老百姓的诉求就是酱简单。

这还只是最近记忆中的几件一马好事,如真正做些搜查,那就真的如你所说。。。罄竹难书。
那些都是你我纳的税钱呐,如何realistic?真的要向前看?聪明的老百姓可没那么大方有耐性。

还只是选择!
懂吗?

有了选择,不好的会变好,好的会变更好!坏的只好到荷兰去。
过了五十多年,好不好是次要,有选择才是目前的硬道理。

ps: 本针英语水皮,用google translate直译还是得到“获得GRIB我的朋友” ,真的抓无路。敬请赐教。

-一针--

HuaYong said...

把我的钱还我,我去泰国剪发,我去新加坡喝酒,我在家拜神。我再也不要看到你用我的钱去英国过圣诞,去美国赌钱,去法国剪发,去澳州买牛(场)。

Anonymous said...

Dear Huayong,

with all due respect, how much tax have u paid?
nothing personal ya dun take it the wrong way

HuaYong said...

u dun even have the capacity to interpret what figure of speech is? how old r u? nothing personal, just curious.

Anonymous said...

U aint paying shit and u were asking for money so u can have hair cut or drink beer anywhere else but malaysia?

its not about figure of speech, i guess something is wrong with ur mentality.

please enlighting me, what do u think u deserve?

HuaYong said...

huh?!? what is your impediment, boy? my point is that I dun mind to get a haircut by lady or take my scotch at overseas if pr choose to ban both, as long as they are willing to take step to improve our living standard via the halt of leakage from corruption and misuse of power. my comment were flowing along within the context of the preceding comments by u guys so do u have reading deficiency or what? not to mention income tax, the moment we own a car we already paid tax unless we were granted ap, which is sort of legalized corruption to enrich the cronies, so what make u think the crony deserve more than me? r u a new comer like those bangladeshi and nepalese or r u not even old enough to possess a driving license hence your puerile view that seem damn ignorant toward the happening here in our country? what garbage!

一针 said...

给的税钱,就算是少,也总比那些把几千几百几万亿黑钱拿到外国去的杀千刀还要多嘛。暂别追究来路如何,这些外流的黑钱又纳了多少税啊?更何况是拿到外国去消费,刺激外国经济,为振兴外国经济出力!
到底一马何方神圣有如此通天过关本领?

2010年2000亿令吉黑钱外流
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。

看来HuaYong也比那些杀千刀的还爱国,根本不用在国庆日升国旗或把国旗插在汽车上做幌子。口喊爱国的可能根本不爱国。小朋友们小心!

【lets be realistic, get a grib my friend. 】

-一针--

Anonymous said...

HY,

your point was : " I dun mind to get a haircut by lady or take my scotch at overseas if pr choose to ban both, as long as they are willing to take step to improve our living standard via the halt of leakage from corruption and misuse of power"

first and foremost i think this is a relatively stupid point becuase,

A: why would u willing to give up your right to have a normal haircut or a scotch? so what are u willing to give up next? if u think u have nothing to lose, then perhaps u may refer to the 4 non muslim that was compounded for khalwat.

B: there is a big "IF" that PR can do anything constructively to improve the current situation.

lets be realistic, and look at the situation in Selangor, Kedah kelantan and penang. penang is good, kelantan n kedah are screwed. and selangor, i wont say they done a terrible job in selangor (execpt for sand mining, illegal MP, talamgate, hindu temple, banning cinema, poor handling of garbage in klang, floods etc).

halting of corruption, erm, not that i can remember. mind to tell me a few example?

anyway its xmas, stop accusing each other something uncalled for. i might have diff pov but it doesnt mean i am lesser malaysian than u.

Anonymous said...

on a sepearte issue, DAP secretay general publicly plead for the use of word allah in malay version of bible. honestly, how low can this man be?

in mankind history, more man are killed in name of god/allah/jesus/tuhan than any deseases or war combined. and this man wish to use "Allah" to gain cheap publicity?

the church never demands for it, and the ppl who actually read malay version bible doesnot care whether it is allah/god/tuhan or whatever. they are not stupid. period.

is this the direction our country is moving into?

HuaYong said...

“ya life is about choice. cant argue on that. however lets be realistic, is the present alternative better than what we have now? we can talk about corruption forever, we can write a book or heck we can make a movie about it. but bottom line is, i had never seen a barber shop closed down, liquor shop closed down….”

My comment was basing on what you wrote, reread please. I am curious again, did u ever read your own comment before replying to others? Your stupid thesis is you concern more about the closing of barber shop and liquor shop (which are lies anyway) than corruption, no?

And I wrote “as long as they are willing to take step to improve our living standard via the halt of leakage from corruption and misuse of power.” to let you know what I expect, can you understand simple English or not? So what realistic are you talking about?

一针 wrote:
八十亿令吉PKFZ。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
5亿令吉潜水艇服务费
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
2.5億令吉养牛门。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
四千万令吉沙巴政治献金。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
一令吉一平方尺卖廿四块地。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。
那该死无耻的地毯商毁谤大家敬爱的尊贵的一马首相及“第一马”夫人。
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你
2010年2000亿令吉黑钱外流
查不查?抓不抓?老老实实查抓,选票归你。

And as usual no answer from typical BN apologist like you again? If PR engage in corruption, it is MACC duty and job to get them, are they sleeping or you are one that sleeping? Gosh it’s like I’m speaking to a person who cannot hear, and writing to a person who cannot read. Perhaps it’s both.

HuaYong said...

"the church never demands for it, and the ppl who actually read malay version bible doesnot care whether it is allah/god/tuhan or whatever."

I am not necessarily agree with LGE but your writing shown that u are either a ignoramus or u r a liar!

Coach Factory said...

nike free, longchamp handbags, air max, coach factory, nike free, toms shoes, prada outlet, nike air max, michael kors outlet online, cheap michael kors, true religion jeans, gucci outlet, michael kors handbags clearance, oakley sunglasses, air jordan, michael kors, coach outlet store, michael kors, nike roshe run, tory burch outlet, chanel handbags, kate spade handbags, nike shoes, oakley sunglasses, prada handbags, michael kors outlet online, louboutin, ray ban sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, jordan shoes, air max, true religion outlet, kate spade outlet, louboutin, nike air max, polo ralph lauren outlet, coach purses, true religion, louis vuitton outlet online, longchamp outlet, michael kors outlet, ray ban, burberry outlet online, tiffany and co, polo ralph lauren outlet, coach outlet, louis vuitton handbags, oakley sunglasses

Coach Factory said...

oakley vault, asics, moncler, herve leger, oakley outlet, oakley sunglasses cheap, cheap oakley, soccer shoes, canada goose, louboutin, moncler, oakley sunglasses outlet, moncler outlet, oakley outlet, oakley sunglasses cheap, ugg boots, moncler, jimmy choo, celine handbags, oakley sunglasses outlet, gucci, ralph lauren, cheap oakley sunglasses, oakley vault, ugg boots, ray ban outlet, canada goose outlet, canada goose, canada goose outlet, ugg boots, p90x, canada goose, oakley sunglasses outlet, tn pas cher, cheap sunglasses, soccer jerseys, oakley outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, cheap oakley sunglasses, cheap sunglasses, oakley, cheap sunglasses, ray ban, canada goose, oakley sunglasses cheap, ray ban, oakley vault, ugg, discount oakley sunglasses

Coach Factory said...

converse shoes, karen millen, lululemon, michael kors, mulberry, mont blanc, nike free, marc jacobs, juicy couture outlet, giuseppe zanotti, valentino shoes, ray ban pas cher, bottega veneta, rolex watches, louis vuitton, air max, birkin bag, louis vuitton, reebok outlet, new balance shoes, instyler ionic styler, ghd, babyliss pro, ralph lauren, abercrombie and fitch, timberland, wedding dresses, north face jackets, north face outlet, hollister, lancel, oakley pas cher, beats by dre, vans, hermes, yoga pants, ferragamo shoes, nfl jerseys, supra shoes, chi flat iron, mcm handbags, burberry, louboutin, hogan, juicy couture outlet, montre pas cher, hollister, louis vuitton, insanity, nike air max