13 July 2012

林冠英身份分裂


辩论源远流长,辩论的目的,就是为了让真理越辩越明,让纠缠不清的争论有所辨识。在大专院校的辩论,考验学生的辩才和智能。
上周(78)举行的蔡林辩论会2.0,对辩论会形式有一定认识的观众,一定会对行动党辩手林冠英在总结辩词时,从头到尾宣读文稿大吃一惊。

明显的,林冠英选读这篇预先备妥的讲稿,纯粹是预设性,并非临场反驳的观点。若双方皆以同样读稿的形式总结辩论,那是演汫比赛。政治座谈会或公共场合致词,读稿很普遍,但考验辩手的敏锐和急智,若照稿宣读就失去辩论的真缔。

辩论会总结陈词一般分为三部分,指出对方错误,例证自己观点和结束语。一般来说,指出错误是要辩手临场的反应。如果总结陈词只是机械化复述己方观点,则会处于败境,正规的大专辩论会中乃识者所不为。陈词固定的部分需要与己方资料有机结合,非固定的部分要靠临场纪录,不是事先就能总结的。

林冠英在辩论后当天下午4.39分,在其个人及行动党官方网站贴上他在双林辩论会发表的总结演讲三语文稿,华文稿字数高达2987个字。令人惊讶的是,林冠英把辩论文稿命题为《林冠英辩论闭幕词》。英文版题为“CLOSING REMARKS BY LIM GUAN ENG ”

蔡、林辩论会2.0的主办单位亚洲策略与领导研究院(ASLI,没有邀请闭幕人来主持闭幕礼并发表演讲,何来辩论闭幕词这一环节?莫非林冠英以辩论会闭幕人自居,在辩论会辩手总结陈词时,发表其预先写好闭幕词?

林冠英身份分裂得让人很难理解这位槟城首席部长到底在搞什么花样。如果他的对手——马华总会长蔡细历也来一个闭幕演讲,闭幕人岂不闹双胞?
如果主办单位原本就有邀请嘉宾为辩论会主持闭幕礼,那么,这位闭幕人在现场聆听辩手发表闭幕词,将因无地自容拂袖而去。

舆论界对蔡、林辩论会辩手的狂妄自大和犯规有所忽略,只因他身居高位,以不得罪为上策。但是,主办当局默许辩手胡作非为,不但对观众不负责任,也影响我国的形象,让人笑话 。所幸,蔡、林双双都关闭第三道辩论会之门,实是华社之幸,否则就是Shame on you
光明日报专栏  是非如流  13-7-2012 

19 comments:

Jack said...

对咯,人家都不要辩了,你还讲这么多干嘛?

一针 said...

哈哈哈哈。。。就是只会把自己困在一个框框内“做”文章。

既然CD佬总不要/不敢再来一场闹剧(是单方面先不玩啦,不是双双,何来双双?),本针就无妨说说私人对这所谓辩论的主观解读吧。无碍各方布局,反正都没续剧看了。。。

为何首长两次辩论大部分时间都照稿宣读政策、愿景?
为何首长照稿宣读的“辩词”都短小精悍,拳拳到肉,容易记忆?
为何明明说好是用英语辩论,首长动动不动就用马来语呢?
(奇怪?。。为何还没有任何马X抢手敢用这点来大“做”文章。看来一点小聪明还是有的。)

是他不会辩论?是他不尊重辩论规则?是他英语不比CD佬总强?。。。用脑袋想想吧,他的预定听众是马X仔、民联支持者吗?

在应付这完全封杀反对党公平运用公共媒体的不要脸政权,说他犯规也罢。。说他胡作非为也罢。。说他不负责任也罢。。说他影响我国的形象也罢。。(谁说辩论不能照稿宣读?谁说辩论不能看猫纸?扣分啦。。。笨!!)只要善用天掉下来难得的机会,只要目的达到,任尔东南西北拍马风!

不正面回答问题的就只是首长一人?
CD佬那种“令伯最大”、“喂。。。喂”、“随意随兴插话反驳”的辩论方式,只适用于“为我独尊逆我者亡”的党内会议。用在真正的辩论会上,只能贻笑大方。

可笑的“得看他脸色搵食”的众马仔马女还猛往CD佬总脸上贴金,猛拍CD佬总马屁。。。。哈哈哈哈。。。可笑的僵党文化!

-一针--

Anonymous said...

这是我从网上抄来的:

蔡林辩论收档后,当你看到资深报人林放和拔牙佬吴启聪等御林军还​要忙摆车轮阵抨击兼反驳林冠英时,恭喜行动党,你们的秘书长赢了​这场辩论。

安东尼老爷 said...

我看您林方先生对槟城人所爱戴的首长林冠英非常感冒,处处为难他,专捉他的痛脚,令他难堪,一点情面都不留给他,这样你的心里就会舒服一点。
林冠英贵人事忙,一天做到晚,日理万机,自顾不暇,忧国忧民,身心疲累,还要上什么辩论会,非常伤神的。所以我们不要怪他在辩论会照预先的讲稿念下去。这样才不会出错。明白吗?我们应该体谅别人。

anakmalaysia said...

Uncle, you sound like a smart person to me. Unfortunately there`s not much time for you, sampai tua lah lu !

fathermalaysia said...

anakmalaysia:
this is the place to comment not mengutuk, let me remind u that coffin alway welcome u n your family too. so,pls mind your language.dun express your difference thinking thru gutuk.

安东尼老爷 said...

father Malaysia,
谢谢您为本老夫仗义执言,说得好!棺材是盖死人的,不是老年人。
留言板本来就是要聆听众人的意见和批评,谁是谁非,不需要和他挑唇料嘴,聪明的读者自有能力判断。

anakmalaysia said...

Mr anthony, The uncle is not you,is uncle Lim Fang.

安东尼老爷 said...

anakmalaysia,

原来你不是指我。
但是你这样说林放先生,你也有失礼不对的地方。
林放先生有他自己的看法,毕竟他是一个资深报人,阅人无数,经验老道的前辈,你有权不同意他的看法和评论,但是你不可以说他老了,时间不多了这样侮辱性难听的话。
有一天你也会老的。记得老人是你们年轻人的一块宝。很多严重的事情发生时,你们年轻人惊慌失措,最后还不是去求老人指点,排除万难。

Anonymous said...

哎呀,老太婆是真的不明白。 It is very clear that Lim fang is a paid lap dog of MCA, so all you PR supporters, why you still bother to read his blog? Do you expect him to write something nice for you? Why do you still bother to comment?

look at all those comments by their so called MCA hardcor supporters who have clearly gone insane with their rubbish, you are just wasting your time trying to argue, you will end up vomiting blood. Why bother to argue with people who are nuts?

So, please listen up guys, just ignore them totally, surely you have better things to do.

老太婆 上

Coach Factory said...

converse shoes, karen millen, lululemon, michael kors, mulberry, mont blanc, nike free, marc jacobs, juicy couture outlet, giuseppe zanotti, valentino shoes, ray ban pas cher, bottega veneta, rolex watches, louis vuitton, air max, birkin bag, louis vuitton, reebok outlet, new balance shoes, instyler ionic styler, ghd, babyliss pro, ralph lauren, abercrombie and fitch, timberland, wedding dresses, north face jackets, north face outlet, hollister, lancel, oakley pas cher, beats by dre, vans, hermes, yoga pants, ferragamo shoes, nfl jerseys, supra shoes, chi flat iron, mcm handbags, burberry, louboutin, hogan, juicy couture outlet, montre pas cher, hollister, louis vuitton, insanity, nike air max

Coach Factory said...

oakley vault, asics, moncler, herve leger, oakley outlet, oakley sunglasses cheap, cheap oakley, soccer shoes, canada goose, louboutin, moncler, oakley sunglasses outlet, moncler outlet, oakley outlet, oakley sunglasses cheap, ugg boots, moncler, jimmy choo, celine handbags, oakley sunglasses outlet, gucci, ralph lauren, cheap oakley sunglasses, oakley vault, ugg boots, ray ban outlet, canada goose outlet, canada goose, canada goose outlet, ugg boots, p90x, canada goose, oakley sunglasses outlet, tn pas cher, cheap sunglasses, soccer jerseys, oakley outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, cheap oakley sunglasses, cheap sunglasses, oakley, cheap sunglasses, ray ban, canada goose, oakley sunglasses cheap, ray ban, oakley vault, ugg, discount oakley sunglasses

Coach Factory said...

nike free, longchamp handbags, air max, coach factory, nike free, toms shoes, prada outlet, nike air max, michael kors outlet online, cheap michael kors, true religion jeans, gucci outlet, michael kors handbags clearance, oakley sunglasses, air jordan, michael kors, coach outlet store, michael kors, nike roshe run, tory burch outlet, chanel handbags, kate spade handbags, nike shoes, oakley sunglasses, prada handbags, michael kors outlet online, louboutin, ray ban sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, jordan shoes, air max, true religion outlet, kate spade outlet, louboutin, nike air max, polo ralph lauren outlet, coach purses, true religion, louis vuitton outlet online, longchamp outlet, michael kors outlet, ray ban, burberry outlet online, tiffany and co, polo ralph lauren outlet, coach outlet, louis vuitton handbags, oakley sunglasses

Weiming Zhu said...

philadelphia eagles jerseys
arizona cardinals jerseys
miami heat jersey
mizuno running
air max 2014
evening dresses
north face jackets
atlanta falcons jersey
canada goose outlet
air jordan 13
the north face outlet store
baltimore ravens jerseys
cleveland cavaliers jersey
new york jets jerseys
bottega veneta outlet
koby bryant shoes
hermes birkin
pittsburgh steelers jersey
los angeles lakers jerseys
oklahoma city thunder jerseys
dansko outlet
north face outlet
nike running shoes
tommy hilfiger outlet
chicago blackhawks jersey
new england patriots jerseys
tory burch outlet
nike outlet store
golden state warriors jerseys
nike free 5.0
air jordan shoes
hermes belt
indianapolis colts jerseys
beats headphones
kate spade outlet
seattle seahawks jerseys
nike free
dallas cowboys jersey
the north face clearance
hermes outlet
denver broncos jerseys

Xiaozhengm 520 said...

ghd flat iron
ralph lauren polo
kate spade handbags
louis vuitton
louis vuitton outlet
lebron james shoes
oakley sunglasses
fitflops
nike roshe flyknit
michael kors outlet
jordan retro 3
timberland boots
louis vuitton handbags
coach outlet
mont blanc
asics outlet
nike blazers
air jordans
michael kors outlet
kate spade
abercrombie
nike air huarache
replica watches
michael kors outlet clearance
ray bans
abercrombie & fitch
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors handbags
retro jordans
vans shoes
coach factory outlet
rolex submariner
michael kors outlet
coach outlet
lebron james shoes 13
michael kors outlet
oakley sunglasses
2016.6.22haungqin

chenlina said...

christian louboutin outlet
coach outlet
coach factory outlet
ugg boots
replica watches
coach outlet
christian louboutin sale
louis vuitton handbags
jordans
nike roshe run
cheap uggs
adidas uk
michael kors outlet
roshe run
air jordans
rolex watches
polo ralph lauren
san antonio spurs jerseys
pandora jewelry
louis vuitton outlet
ugg boots
ugg store
abercrombie outlet
oakley sunglasses
christian louboutin shoes
fitflops
dallas mavericks jerseys
chicago bulls jerseys
ralph lauren uk
louis vuitton handbags
moncler uk
louis vuitton paris
adidas originals
michael kors handbags
true religion outlet
oakley sunglasses
mont blanc pens
rolex watches
adidas originals shoes
louis vuitton handbags
chenlina20160901

龙大猫 said...

cheap basketball shoes
michael kors outlet store
adidas ultra boost 3.0
chrome hearts online
reebok outlet
nmd r1
adidas ultra boost
adidas nmd r1
patriots jersey
adidas nmd r1

adidas nmd said...

philadelphia eagles jerseys
cheap oakley sunglasses
nike air huarache
ralph lauren
montblanc pens
steelers jerseys
ecco shoes
nike free 5
cheap nike shoes sale
pandora jewelry

happy 123 said...

adidas stan smith
michael kors purses
kobe sneakers
yeezy boost
jordan shoes
dior glasses
jordan retro
nike air huarache
michael kors outlet store
nmd